On International Human Rights Day, December 10th 2013, the Online Hate Prevention Institute (OHPI) have released a major new report into the growing problem of online hate targeting the Muslim community. The full report, titled ‘Islamophobia on the Internet: The growth of online hate targeting Muslims’, is available below as a free download.
The report examines anti-Muslim hate on Facebook and was produced by the Online Hate Prevention Institute, Australia’s only charity entirely dedicated to the growing problem of online hate. We thank the Islamic Council of Victoria, the peak body representing Victoria’s Muslim community, who we consulted regularly in the preparation of this report. The report follows previous major works by OHPI examining online hate against Indigenous Australians, the Jewish Community, and the ANZACs and Military Veterans.
This major work examines 50 anti-Muslim Facebook pages. The Facebook pages range from “The Islamic threat” which today passed the 113,000 supporter mark and continues to rapidly grow, to “Mohammad the PIG” which vanished after reaching 2000 supporters. From these 50 pages the report documents 349 images of anti-Muslim hate. These images represent 191 unique images and many repetitions as messages of hate move between the different pages. The message of hate in this report are divided into seven themes which the report discusses.
The themes of anti-Muslim hate and an illustrative example of each:
Muslims as a Security Threat or Threat to Public Safety
Muslims as a Cultural Threat
Muslims as an Economic Threat
Content Dehumanising or Demonizing Muslims
Threats of Violence, Genocide and Direct Hate Targeting Muslims
Hate Targeting Refugees / Asylum Seekers
Other Forms of Hate Speech
(These typically seek to create acceptability for religious vilification of Muslims, or to suggest Muslims who speak out against extremism are part of a conspiracy.)
American, British and Australian nationals provide the highest level of support to these pages of hate. Of the pages examined 13 of them were specifically Australian in nature. Pages like “Look after Australians first deport all illegal boatpeople”, and “Australian Defence League Official Adl Est 2009”.
This report aims to highlight the existence of what is a serious hate speech problem on Facebook. To the extent that this content gives a window into the hate speech against Muslims that is currently circulating in society, we hope this report assists community leaders, policy makers, law makers and researchers in better understanding and responding to this threat to an inclusive society. In democracies inclusiveness is regarded as a public good, as such, this hate speech is not only an attack on the Muslim community but an attack on society as a whole. We must work together to tackle this growing problem.
The response so far from Facebook has been deeply disappointing:
- The foreword from the Islamic Council of Victoria
- The Executive Summary to the Report
- Selected extracts from Statements of Support for the report.
- The Nature Of Anti-Muslim Hate (extract, pages 8–9 of the report)
The provided extracts are from statements of support from:
- The Hon Mark Dreyfus QC MP
- The Hon John Brumby
- Ghaith Krayem (Islamic Council of Victoria)
- Prof. Andrew Jakubowicz
- Dr Hass Dellal OAM (Australian Multicultural Foundation)
- Peter Wertheim AM (Executive Council of Australian Jewry)
- Priscilla Brice (All Together Now)
- Dr Dvir Abramovich (B’nai B’rith Anti-Defamation Commission)
- Craig Rowley (LeadWest)
- Nina Bassat AM (Jewish Community Council of Victoria)
Journalists, bloggers, and relevant organisations and governmental departments wishing to receive a copy of the report before December 10th should e-mail OHPI.
Media and Blog Coverage
- Sarah AB, Satire or smear? Islam-themed cartoons, BobFromBrockley, 11 December 2013
- Facebook criticized for not stopping racism, Expo IDAG, 10 December 2013 (in Swedish)
- ABC Radio National, ‘Muslims Trolled’, Drive, 10 December 2013 7:23pm (Waleed Aly interviews Andre Oboler).
- Omar Sacirbey, MoozWeek: The Muslim 500 * Fox faux pas * People’s poet, Religion News Service, December 6 2013
- Press release, Rising Hate Against Muslims on Facebook, December 5 2013
- Sarah AB, OHPI and online anti-Muslim bigotry, Harry’s Place, December 4th 2013
- Islamophobia on the Internet: Major new report exposes online hate targeting Muslims, Ahlul Bayt News Agency, December 4th 2013
- Bob Pitt, Islamophobia on the Internet: Major new report exposes online hate targeting Muslims, Islamophobia Watch, December 3 2013